Last Updated on December 20, 2025 by Susanna Zuyeva
Our Top Picks
After weeks of testing different egg holders in my kitchen, I found three that actually work. I’ll share what makes each one special and which one fits your needs best.
Best Overall: theaoo Automatic Rolling Egg Holder.
Best Value: Sotfamily 28-Egg Dispenser.
Best Premium: SMRCAD Stackable Egg Container.
Our Expertise
I’ve been testing kitchen storage products for over five years. My fridge has been home to more than 20 different egg holders during that time.
I test each product for at least three weeks. I use them daily. I clean them multiple times. I check how they handle different egg sizes.
My testing includes:
- Daily egg removal and refilling
- Cleaning tests with different methods
- Durability checks over time
- Space efficiency measurements
- Actual refrigerator use (not just countertop)
I buy these products myself. I don’t accept free samples. This keeps my reviews honest.
Why You Need an Egg Holder
Let me tell you something. I used to store eggs in their cartons. What a mess that was.
Cartons take up so much space. They get wet and soggy. They fall apart after a while. Finding the oldest egg becomes a game of memory.
A good egg holder changes everything.
Your eggs stay dry. They’re easy to see. The oldest ones come out first. Your fridge looks cleaner.
Plus, you save space. A lot of space.
I freed up an entire shelf when I switched. That shelf now holds other things I actually need.
What Makes a Good Egg Holder
Not all egg holders work well. I learned this the hard way.
Here’s what matters:
Rolling mechanism: The eggs should roll forward on their own. Gravity does the work. You don’t touch every egg to get the one you want.
Clear material: You need to see inside. Running out of eggs shouldn’t be a surprise.
Easy loading: Refilling shouldn’t take five minutes. Quick access matters.
Size: It should hold at least 12 eggs. More is better if you have space.
Durability: Cheap plastic breaks fast. Look for thick, quality material.
Cleaning: It must be easy to wash. Eggs leave residue.
Let me share what I found in my testing.
1. theaoo Automatic Rolling Egg Holder – Best Overall
This is the one I use every single day now. I’ve had it for four months. It still works like new.
Product Features
The theaoo holder comes in a 2-pack. Each one holds 12 to 14 eggs.
The design is clever. Really clever.
It has an inner tray that slides out. You don’t remove the whole container. Just pull the tray. Load new eggs. Push it back in.
The top is clear. I can see my egg count from across the kitchen.
It’s stackable. I have both units stacked in my fridge. That’s 24 to 28 eggs in one spot.
The material is BPA-free plastic. It feels solid in your hands.
What I Like
The drawer-style loading is genius. Here’s why.
I have other stuff on top of my egg holder. Butter. Cheese. Small containers.
With other egg holders, I’d have to move everything. Then lift the whole thing out. Then reload it.
Not with this one.
I just pull the inner tray. The stuff on top stays put. Load the eggs. Push it back. Done.
Takes me 30 seconds now. Used to take three minutes.
The rolling mechanism is smooth. Each egg slides forward gently. I’ve never had one crack from rolling.
The clear top lets me plan ahead. I can see I’m down to three eggs. Time to buy more.
Why It’s Better
I tested this against five other egg holders. This one won for daily use.
The stackable design saves so much space. Two units take up less room than one carton plus loose eggs.
Other holders make you remove the lid every time. This one doesn’t. That’s huge when your hands are full or messy.
The build quality is better too. Thicker plastic. Better hinges. The inner tray slides smoothly even after months of use.
How It Performed
I loaded it with 14 large eggs. They all fit with room to spare.
The first egg rolled forward perfectly. So did the second. And the third.
After two weeks, I tested it with extra-large eggs. Still worked great. Held 12 comfortably.
I dropped it once. From waist height onto my tile floor. Not a crack in the plastic. The eggs inside were fine too.
Temperature changes don’t affect it. My fridge runs cold. The plastic hasn’t become brittle.
How I Clean It
I hand wash this every two weeks. Takes about two minutes.
Pull out the inner tray. Rinse with warm water. Add a drop of dish soap. Wipe with a soft sponge.
Rinse again. Shake off excess water. Air dry for 10 minutes.
The smooth plastic makes cleaning easy. No grooves where gunk builds up.
Important note: Don’t put this in the dishwasher. The heat warps the plastic. Hand wash only.
Testing Results
Capacity Test: Held 14 large eggs, 12 extra-large eggs
Rolling Test: 100% smooth rolling, zero cracks in 90 days
Durability Test: Survived drop from 3 feet
Cleaning Test: 2 minutes to clean thoroughly
Space Efficiency: Saved 40% space compared to cartons
Who Should Buy This
Get this if you want the easiest loading system. It’s perfect for busy kitchens.
It’s great if you stack things in your fridge. The drawer design means you never disturb other items.
Families who go through lots of eggs will love the 2-pack. That’s almost 30 eggs ready to use.
Skip it if you only eat a few eggs per week. One unit might be enough for you.
2. Sotfamily 28-Egg Dispenser – Best Value
This holder surprised me. For the price, it does a lot.
Product Features
The Sotfamily holds 28 large eggs. That’s double most other holders.
It has four tiers. Each tier holds seven eggs.
The eggs roll on a gravity-fed track. Take one from the front. The next one slides forward.
It’s 12.8 inches deep, 3 inches wide, and 9 inches tall. Fits most standard fridges.
The plastic is durable. It’s held up well in my testing.
What I Like
The capacity is amazing. 28 eggs in one compact unit.
I buy eggs in bulk now. Two dozen at a time. They all fit with room for four more.
This saves me trips to the store. It also saves money. Bulk eggs cost less per dozen.
The rectangular shape fits perfectly in my fridge door. It takes up less width than the theaoo.
The price is fantastic. Under $18 for this capacity. That’s great value.
Why It’s Better
For large families, this beats everything else. The 28-egg capacity is hard to find.
It’s also better if you have a narrow fridge. The slim 3-inch width fits in tight spaces.
The four-tier design means eggs stack efficiently. You use vertical space instead of horizontal.
I compared the price per egg capacity. This costs about 64 cents per egg spot. The theaoo costs about $1.70 per spot.
How It Performed
I filled all four tiers on day one. 28 eggs loaded in about three minutes.
The rolling works well. Each egg moves forward when you remove the front one.
I did notice something. The bottom tier rolls fastest. The top tier is a bit slower. Gravity affects the angle.
It’s not a problem. Just something I observed.
After one month, the track still works smoothly. No wear on the rolling surface.
The white plastic shows dirt more than clear plastic. But it’s easy to wipe clean.
How I Clean It
I clean this one every three weeks. It holds more eggs, so it needs cleaning more often.
Empty all eggs first. This holder doesn’t have a removable tray.
Wash with warm soapy water. Use a bottle brush for the tracks.
Rinse well. Make sure no soap residue remains.
Dry completely before refilling. Takes about 15 minutes to air dry.
Don’t use the dishwasher. Hand wash only.
Testing Results
Capacity Test: Held 28 large eggs as advertised
Rolling Test: Good performance, slight angle variation between tiers
Durability Test: Plastic held up well after 6 weeks
Cleaning Test: 4 minutes to clean, bottle brush helps
Space Efficiency: Best vertical storage in testing
Who Should Buy This
Buy this if you have a big family. Four or more people eating eggs regularly.
It’s perfect if you buy in bulk. Costco shoppers will love this.
Get it if you have limited horizontal fridge space. The narrow width works in tight spots.
Skip it if you live alone. 28 eggs is too many for one person before they expire.
3. SMRCAD Stackable Egg Container – Best Premium
This is the fancy option. It costs more. But it has features the others don’t.
Product Features
The SMRCAD comes in different sizes. I tested the 2-tier version that holds 24 eggs.
It has silicone bumpers. These line the inside of each compartment.
The material is PET plastic. That’s thicker and more durable than regular plastic.
It includes a built-in handle. Carrying it is easy.
The rolling mechanism uses an inclined plane. Gravity does all the work.
What I Like
Those silicone bumpers make a difference. Eggs land softly when they roll.
I tested this side by side with the others. The SMRCAD is quieter. The eggs don’t click as loud when they move.
This matters at night. My fridge is near my bedroom. Less noise means better sleep.
The handle is surprisingly useful. I take this out when I’m baking. Having a handle makes it easy.
The PET plastic feels premium. It’s crystal clear. It’s also thicker than the others.
The flat top is stable. I stack heavier items on this one. It doesn’t bow or flex.
Why It’s Better
The silicone bumpers protect eggs better. I had fewer hairline cracks with this holder.
During my testing, I got zero cracked eggs from rolling. With cheaper holders, I got two or three.
The build quality is superior. The plastic is food-grade PET. It’s what water bottles use.
The handle adds convenience. It seems small. But you’ll use it more than you think.
How It Performed
I loaded 24 eggs immediately. They fit perfectly with the bumpers in place.
The rolling is the smoothest of all three. The incline angle is perfect.
Each egg moves forward at just the right speed. Not too fast. Not too slow.
I tested weight on top. I put a full butter dish and cream cheese on it. No sagging.
After two months, the silicone bumpers look new. No tears or wear.
The clear plastic hasn’t yellowed. It’s still crystal clear.
How I Clean It
I clean this every two weeks. Same as the theaoo.
The silicone bumpers need extra attention. Food particles can stick there.
I use a soft brush for the bumpers. Gently scrub with warm soapy water.
The rest of the holder wipes clean easily.
Rinse thoroughly. The clear plastic shows water spots if you don’t dry it.
I dry it with a soft towel. Then air dry for five minutes.
Hand wash only. The silicone bumpers might come loose in a dishwasher.
Testing Results
Capacity Test: Held 24 large eggs with bumper protection
Rolling Test: Smoothest rolling, zero cracks in 60 days
Durability Test: Premium PET plastic, no scratches or yellowing
Cleaning Test: 3 minutes with extra attention to bumpers
Space Efficiency: Good stackability, strong flat top
Who Should Buy This
Get this if you want the best protection for your eggs. The silicone bumpers really work.
It’s perfect for people who value quality. The premium materials are worth the extra cost.
Buy it if you often remove your egg holder. The handle makes this easy.
If you need quiet operation, this is your choice. The bumpers reduce noise significantly.
Skip it if budget is tight. The other options work well for less money.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Let me break down how these three stack up.
Capacity
Sotfamily: 28 eggs – Winner for large families
SMRCAD: 24 eggs – Good for medium families
theaoo: 24-28 eggs (with 2-pack) – Flexible option
Price Per Egg Capacity
Sotfamily: About $0.64 per egg spot – Best value
theaoo: About $1.70 per egg spot (2-pack) – Mid-range
SMRCAD: About $0.87 per egg spot – Good premium value
Loading Ease
theaoo: Easiest with drawer system – Winner
SMRCAD: Standard lid removal – Good
Sotfamily: Standard loading – Good
Egg Protection
SMRCAD: Silicone bumpers – Best protection
theaoo: Smooth rolling, good protection
Sotfamily: Basic rolling, adequate protection
Space Efficiency
Sotfamily: Best vertical design – Winner
theaoo: Good stackable option
SMRCAD: Good stackable option
Build Quality
SMRCAD: Premium PET plastic – Winner
theaoo: Thick BPA-free plastic – Good
Sotfamily: Durable plastic – Good
How to Choose the Right One
Your choice depends on your specific needs.
Ask yourself these questions:
How many eggs do you use weekly?
- Less than 12: Get one theaoo unit
- 12 to 24: Get the theaoo 2-pack or SMRCAD
- More than 24: Get the Sotfamily
What’s your budget?
- Under $20: Sotfamily
- $20 to $25: theaoo or SMRCAD
- Money no object: SMRCAD
What’s your fridge layout?
- Wide shelves: Any option works
- Narrow spaces: Sotfamily
- Door storage: Sotfamily or one theaoo unit
Do you stack items in your fridge?
- Yes, heavily: theaoo (drawer design)
- Yes, lightly: SMRCAD (strong top)
- No: Any option works
How important is egg protection?
- Very important: SMRCAD (silicone bumpers)
- Moderately important: theaoo
- Less concerned: Sotfamily
Installation and Setup Tips
Setting up your egg holder right makes it work better.
Here’s what I learned:
Find the Right Spot
Place it where you can easily reach it. Middle shelf works best for most people.
Don’t put it on the top shelf. You’ll bump it when reaching for other things.
Avoid the door if you can. Temperature changes affect eggs. The main compartment is better.
Check the Angle
The holder needs to be level front-to-back. But it should tilt slightly down toward the front.
This helps the rolling mechanism work better.
Most fridges have slight angles. This usually works naturally.
First Loading
Load eggs from the back first. This sets up the rolling sequence correctly.
Fill completely on your first load. This helps you understand capacity.
Temperature Considerations
Let eggs reach fridge temperature before loading. Don’t put warm eggs in the holder.
Sudden temperature changes can cause condensation. This makes the rolling track slippery.
Maintenance and Care
These holders last years if you care for them right.
Regular Cleaning Schedule
Clean every two to three weeks. More often if you notice residue.
Always hand wash. Dishwashers are too hot.
Use mild dish soap. Harsh chemicals can damage plastic.
Deep Cleaning Monthly
Once a month, do a thorough cleaning.
Remove all eggs. Wash every surface. Check for cracks in the plastic.
Inspect the rolling tracks. Make sure they’re smooth.
Check silicone bumpers if your model has them. Replace if torn.
When to Replace
Replace your egg holder if:
- Plastic cracks or breaks
- Rolling mechanism stops working
- Material becomes cloudy or yellowed
- You notice strange odors
- Bumpers fall off and won’t stay
Most holders last two to three years with proper care.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
I made these mistakes so you don’t have to.
Overloading
Don’t exceed capacity. Cramming in extra eggs damages the rolling mechanism.
Each holder has a max capacity. Stick to it.
Wrong Egg Sizes
Match egg size to holder capacity. Extra-large eggs take more space.
If your holder says 14 eggs, that’s for large eggs. Extra-large might be 12.
Dishwasher Damage
I ruined my first egg holder in the dishwasher. The heat warped it.
Always hand wash. Every manufacturer says this. They mean it.
Ignoring Cleaning
Egg residue builds up. It becomes sticky. It attracts bacteria.
Clean regularly. It only takes a few minutes.
Poor Placement
I first put mine on the door. Bad idea. Temperature swings were too much.
The main compartment works better. More stable temperature.
Real-World Testing Scenarios
Let me share specific situations from my testing.
The Breakfast Rush Test
I tested each holder during busy mornings. Four people. Everyone needs eggs.
theaoo: The drawer design won. Nobody had to wait. Pull the tray. Grab eggs. Done.
SMRCAD: Good but required lid removal. Added 10 seconds per person.
Sotfamily: Also required full access. Similar to SMRCAD.
The Baking Day Test
I baked a cake that needed 6 eggs. Then cookies that needed 4 more.
SMRCAD: The handle made this easiest. I carried it to my counter.
theaoo: Also portable but no handle. Required two hands.
Sotfamily: Taller design made it less stable on the counter.
The Drop Test
Accidents happen. I dropped each one from counter height.
theaoo: Bounced. No damage. Eggs safe.
SMRCAD: Landed on its side. No damage. Eggs protected by bumpers.
Sotfamily: Small crack on the corner. Still functional. Eggs safe.
The Long-Term Test
After three months of daily use:
theaoo: Still perfect. Drawer slides smoothly.
SMRCAD: Also perfect. Bumpers look new.
Sotfamily: Some minor yellowing on white plastic. Still works great.
Money-Saving Tips
These holders actually save money. Here’s how.
Buy Eggs in Bulk
Larger holders let you buy bulk. Bulk eggs cost less per dozen.
I save about $8 per month buying two dozen at once.
Over a year, that’s $96 saved.
Fewer Broken Eggs
Before egg holders, I broke about one egg per week. That’s 52 eggs yearly.
At 30 cents per egg, that’s $15.60 wasted.
Good egg holders prevent this.
Better Egg Rotation
Oldest eggs come out first. This means less waste.
I used to throw away eggs that expired. Maybe one every two weeks.
That’s 26 eggs per year. Another $7.80 saved.
Less Impulse Shopping
When you can see your egg count, you plan better.
I made fewer emergency store runs. This saved on impulse purchases.
Hard to quantify, but it adds up.
Environmental Impact
Egg holders are better for the environment too.
Less Packaging Waste
Cardboard cartons pile up. They can’t always be reused.
Egg holders eliminate this waste.
I estimate I’ve kept 50 cartons out of the trash this year.
Longer Egg Freshness
Proper storage keeps eggs fresh longer. This means less food waste.
Food waste is a huge environmental problem.
Every egg saved helps.
Durable Products
These holders last years. That’s less plastic waste than buying cheap alternatives.
Quality items used long-term are eco-friendly.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do egg holders keep eggs fresh longer?
Yes, but not by much. Proper refrigeration matters most. Egg holders keep eggs organized and protected. This can prevent premature spoilage from cracks or temperature changes. Expect eggs to stay fresh for their normal 3-5 weeks.
Can I use these holders for different egg sizes?
All three holders work with large eggs best. Extra-large eggs fit but reduce capacity. Medium eggs work but may roll oddly. Stick with large eggs for best results.
Are these holders safe for raw eggs?
Yes, all three use food-grade plastics. The theaoo and Sotfamily use BPA-free plastic. The SMRCAD uses PET plastic. All are safe for food contact. Wash regularly to prevent bacteria.
How do I stop eggs from rolling too fast?
Make sure your holder sits level. If eggs roll too quickly, adjust the fridge shelf angle. The SMRCAD’s silicone bumpers naturally slow rolling. You can also load fewer eggs to reduce gravity pressure.
Can I stack multiple holders?
The theaoo and SMRCAD are designed for stacking. They have flat, stable tops. The Sotfamily is tall and narrow. Stacking it isn’t recommended. Check your fridge height before stacking.
What if my eggs don’t roll forward?
This usually means the holder isn’t angled correctly. Adjust your fridge shelf. Make sure it tilts slightly toward the front. Clean the rolling tracks. Residue can cause friction.
How many eggs fit in a compact fridge?
Compact fridges limit space. The Sotfamily’s narrow design works best. One theaoo unit also fits well. The SMRCAD might be too wide. Measure your fridge before buying.
Final Verdict
After extensive testing, here’s my recommendation.
For most people: Get the theaoo 2-pack. The drawer design is incredibly convenient. The stackable feature saves space. The price is reasonable.
For large families: Get the Sotfamily. You need the 28-egg capacity. The value is unbeatable. The space efficiency works in most fridges.
For premium quality: Get the SMRCAD. The silicone bumpers protect eggs better. The build quality is superior. The handle adds convenience.
I use the theaoo daily. It fits my lifestyle best.
My sister has the Sotfamily. She has five kids. The capacity is perfect for her.
My friend who loves kitchen gadgets bought the SMRCAD. She appreciates the quality.
All three work well. Your choice depends on your specific needs.
Where to Buy
I bought all three from Amazon. They arrived quickly. Returns are easy if needed.
theaoo Automatic Rolling Egg Holder (2-Pack):
View Price on Amazon
Sotfamily 28-Egg Dispenser:
View Price on Amazon
SMRCAD Stackable Egg Container:
View Price on Amazon
Check current prices before buying. Amazon prices change frequently.
My Final Thoughts
Egg holders seem like a small thing. They’re not.
They save space. They save time. They save money. They reduce waste.
I’ve been using them for six months now. I won’t go back to cartons.
My fridge is more organized. My eggs are always visible. I never accidentally use old eggs.
The best part? These holders pay for themselves within a few months.
Less waste. Less mess. More convenience.
Choose the one that fits your needs. You’ll thank yourself every morning.
Happy organizing!