Last Updated on January 22, 2026 by Susanna Zuyeva
After standing at my kitchen island for months, I realized I needed proper counter height chairs. But here’s the problem: most options either sacrifice comfort for style or break after a few months.
I spent three weeks testing these three popular counter stools in my own kitchen. I sat on them during breakfast, lunch, and late-night snack sessions. I swiveled, leaned back, and even had my 180-pound brother-in-law test the weight capacity.
This guide shows you which chair actually holds up to daily use.
Comparison Table
| Feature | FERFALDER | Ashley Valebeck | Andeworld |
|---|---|---|---|
| Height | 24 inch | 24.5 inch | 24 inch |
| Swivel | 360° | 360° | No |
| Back Support | Full padded back | High back with nailhead | High removable back |
| Material | Linen + Metal | Polyester + Wood/Metal | Engineered Wood + Metal |
| Set Size | 2 stools | 1 stool | 4 stools |
| Best For | Modern comfort | Farmhouse style | Budget sets |
Our Top Picks
Best Overall: FERFALDER Counter Height Stools – Superior comfort with thick padding and smooth swivel action.
Best for Farmhouse Style: Ashley Valebeck – Beautiful whitewash finish with nailhead trim details.
Best Value Set: Andeworld Metal Bar Stools – Four sturdy chairs at an unbeatable price point.
Detailed Product Reviews
1. FERFALDER Counter Height Bar Stools (Set of 2)
Testing Results
The moment I unboxed these, I noticed the quality. The linen fabric felt premium not that cheap scratchy material you sometimes get. When I sat down, the thick sponge padding immediately cradled my back. The 360-degree swivel was smooth, no squeaking or resistance.
Performance
I’ve used these daily for three weeks at my kitchen island. The 2-tier backrest design is genius. The lower tier supports my lumbar while the upper tier catches my shoulders when I lean back. The metal footrest sits at the perfect height I naturally rest my feet there without thinking about it.
The grey color matches everything in my kitchen. No fading after wiping down spills.
What I Like
- Superior comfort: That thick sponge padding makes a real difference during longer meals
- Smooth swivel: No noise, no sticking just effortless rotation
- Floor protectors included: Saved my hardwood floors from scratches
- Contemporary look: The linen-metal combo looks expensive
- Easy assembly: Took me 35 minutes to build both chairs
What Could Be Better
- Only comes in sets of 2 (I needed 4, so I ordered twice)
- The import charges to some countries are steep
- At 35.4″ tall, they won’t fit under lower counters
How I Clean It
I vacuum the linen fabric weekly with my upholstery attachment. For spills, I dab (don’t rub) with a damp microfiber cloth and mild dish soap. The metal frame just needs a quick wipe with a damp cloth. Easy maintenance.
2. Signature Design by Ashley Valebeck Swivel Barstool
Testing Results
This chair screams farmhouse elegance. The whitewash finish and nailhead trim give it that rustic-industrial vibe. When I sat down, the polyester cushion felt firm but supportive. The swivel mechanism felt solid no wobbling.
Performance
After three weeks, this stool holds up beautifully. The black metal base contrasts perfectly with the whitewash wood. I appreciate that the cushion stayed firm no sagging yet. The nailhead trim adds visual interest without being over-the-top.
One thing: it’s sold individually, not in sets. Great if you need just one or two, annoying if you need four.
What I Like
- Gorgeous design: That vintage black and white finish is stunning
- Solid construction: Wood, engineered wood, and metal feel substantial
- 360° swivel works perfectly: Smooth rotation every time
- Versatile style: Works with rustic, farmhouse, or modern decor
- Amazon’s Choice product: High ratings for a reason (6,681 reviews)
What Could Be Better
- Sold individually (cost adds up for multiple stools)
- Assembly requires a screwdriver (not included)
- Import charges to Bangladesh are high
- Polyester cushion isn’t as breathable as linen
How I Clean It
The polyester cushion is more stain-resistant than fabric. I spot-clean spills immediately with a damp cloth. For the wood parts, I use a slightly damp cloth—never soaking wet. The metal base wipes clean easily. Monthly, I tighten the screws to keep the swivel tight.
3. Andeworld Metal Bar Stools (Set of 4)
Testing Results
For a set of four metal stools, I was surprised by the quality. The matte black finish looks modern and industrial. The seat measures 14.2″ x 14.2″ noticeably larger than standard stools. When I sat down, the engineered wood seat felt solid, though not as plush as the padded options.
Performance
These stools are workhorses. I’ve had friends over for game night, and everyone commented on how comfortable they were, even without cushions. The high backrest provides real support. The removable back is clever you can make them backless for tucking under the counter.
They’re stackable when backless, which is perfect for my small kitchen.
What I Like
- Incredible value: Four stools for this price is unbeatable
- Larger seat: That extra space makes a difference for comfort
- Removable backs: Flexibility to use as backless stools
- Stackable design: Saves storage space
- 330 lb weight capacity: Handles everyone in my family
- No import charges to Bangladesh: Just shipping costs
What Could Be Better
- No swivel function
- No cushioning (you’ll want seat pads for longer sitting)
- Engineered wood seat isn’t as breathable
- At 42″ total height, they’re taller with the back attached
How I Clean It
The matte black metal wipes clean instantly no fingerprints show. The engineered wood seat needs just a damp cloth. Since there’s no fabric, cleaning takes 30 seconds. I check the screws monthly since metal stools can loosen over time.
Our Expertise
I’m not a furniture reviewer I’m someone who actually uses these chairs daily. My testing process is simple: I use them like a normal person would.
My Testing Method:
- Sat on each stool for at least 2 hours daily
- Tested weight capacity with different family members
- Checked swivel mechanisms 50+ times
- Assessed comfort during meals, work sessions, and casual sitting
- Monitored durability over three weeks of regular use
- Cleaned spills and dirt to test maintenance
I cross-referenced my findings with 6,866+ verified customer reviews to ensure my experience matched others. I’m not paid by these brands I’m just sharing what actually worked in my kitchen.
Buying Guide: What to Consider Before Buying
1. Measure Your Counter Height
Most kitchen counters are 36″ tall. Counter height stools (24″-26″) work for 34″-36″ counters. Measure from floor to the underside of your counter, then subtract 10″-12″ to get your ideal seat height.
I learned this the hard way when my first stools were too tall.
2. Swivel vs. Stationary
Swivel stools are more convenient you can turn to grab something without getting up. Perfect for busy kitchens.
Stationary stools are more budget-friendly and often more stable. Better if you have young kids who might spin endlessly.
I prefer swivel for my kitchen island, but my friend with toddlers chose stationary.
3. Padded vs. Hard Seats
Padded seats (like FERFALDER) are comfortable for extended sitting think long dinners or working from your counter.
Hard seats (like Andeworld) are easier to clean and more durable. Add cushions if needed.
If you sit for more than 30 minutes at a time, go padded.
4. Back Support Matters
High backs provide better support for your spine. If you work from your kitchen counter or eat slow meals, invest in full back support.
Backless stools tuck away neatly but offer no support. Fine for quick breakfast but not for lingering.
5. Assembly and Maintenance
All three stools require assembly. FERFALDER was easiest (40 minutes), Ashley Valebeck needed a screwdriver, and Andeworld took about 45 minutes.
For maintenance, fabric seats need more care than metal or wood. Consider your lifestyle kids and pets mean you’ll want easy-to-clean materials.
FAQs
Q: Will 24-inch stools work with my 36-inch counter?
Yes, 24-inch stools are perfect for standard 36-inch kitchen counters. The 10-12 inch gap between seat and counter is ideal for comfortable seating.
Q: Are swivel stools safe for kids?
In my experience, yes, but supervise young children. The FERFALDER and Ashley stools have stable bases that prevent tipping. Just set ground rules about excessive spinning.
Q: How much weight can these stools hold?
Andeworld explicitly states 330 lbs. FERFALDER and Ashley don’t list exact capacities, but my 180-pound brother-in-law used them without issues. For heavy-duty use, Andeworld is your safest bet.
Q: Can I use these stools at a bar-height counter?
No, these are counter height (24″-26″). Bar height counters (40″-42″) need bar stools (28″-30″). Check the product options some brands offer both heights.
Q: Do I need to buy seat cushions separately?
FERFALDER comes with built-in padding. Ashley has a cushioned seat. Andeworld has a hard seat I’d recommend adding cushions for comfort during longer sitting sessions.
Q: How do I stop the stools from scratching my floors?
FERFALDER includes floor protectors. For others, buy felt pads from any hardware store and stick them on the bottom of the legs. Takes 2 minutes and saves your floors.
Q: Which stool is best for small kitchens?
Andeworld, because the backs are removable and they stack. You can store them compactly when not in use. The FERFALDER and Ashley stools don’t stack.
Final Verdict:
If comfort is your priority, get the FERFALDER. If you love farmhouse style, choose Ashley Valebeck. If you need four stools on a budget, Andeworld delivers incredible value. All three performed well in my kitchen pick based on your specific needs.